Name: Grove Hotel
Address: P.O. Box 4199 Main Walk Cherry Grove 11782 New York, Fire Island, Fire Island, Fire Island, 11782, United States of America
Rating: 6

Location

Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre

Carrington House

Sunken Forest

Long Island MacArthur Airport

Republic Airport

Francis S. Gabreski Airport

Igor I. Sikorsky Memorial Airport

John F. Kennedy International Airport

Grove Hotel

Fire Island

child-bed

child-bed-fee

external-private-bathroom

private-bathroom

shared-bathroom

10-beds

11-beds

12-beds

13-beds

14-beds

15-beds

16-beds

17-beds

18-beds

19-beds

2-beds

20-beds

21-beds

22-beds

23-beds

24-beds

25-beds

26-beds

27-beds

28-beds

29-beds

3-beds

30-beds

31-beds

32-beds

33-beds

34-beds

35-beds

36-beds

37-beds

38-beds

39-beds

4-beds

40-beds

5-beds

6-beds

7-beds

8-beds

9-beds

king-bed

queen-bed

limited-time

lounge

treatment

no-window

bay-view

bosphorus-view

canal-view

city-view

courtyard-view

garden-view

golf-view

harbour-view

inland-view

lake-view

land-view

mountain-view

ocean-front

ocean-view

oceanside

panoramic-view

park-view

partial-ocean-view

partial-sea-view

partial-view

pool-view

river-view

sea-front

sea-view

street-view

sunrise-view

sunset-view

water-view

with-view

annex

basement

main-building

1-bedroom

2-bedrooms

3-bedrooms

4-bedrooms

5-bedrooms

6-bedrooms

not-guaranteed

wired-internet-access

smoking

sauna

duplex

safe

mini-bar

breakfast-for-1

breakfast-for-2

pets-allowed

wi-fi

kitchen

Nice renovation rooms are a lot nicer than the previous old hotel.
Pool was open and lots of people seemed to ge having a great time.
Ice Palace nightclub was fun and frolic as usual.
Only drawback for me is the complete lack of any counter space in the bathroom.
Nowhere to set down you toiletries and cosmetics just a free standing sink and zero space for products.
All in all I love this place and shall return again and again as I have been doing since 2006.

A happy time in Cherry Grove.

We arrived to finding out the pool and outdoor deck were under construction;  we were never advised when we made the reservation, and hotel management were not helpful. They eventually offered us a 10% discount for our troubles. 
Unprofessional and front desk staff were unsympathetic. 

Totally disappointing 

My friends & I had a great weekend on FI staying here! Super convenient, friendly staff, great location. Just a little beach hotel nothing fancy- the ice machine didn't work, we killed a bug or two in the room- but overall a great stay for a casual friend party weekend for sure! 
We were also in one of the newly renovated rooms & were pleasantly surprised with how nice it was! 
Would deff return. 

Convenient & casual beach stay! 

It was clean. Small. Plain. But had what it needed. I was concerned that I would hear people in the rooms above and next door but we didn’t. This place can use a little decoration  on the walls. But it was fine for what it was. I was only here for one night. I wouldnt stay for much more than that. Front staff megan was really nicer 

Ok for what it is 

It's a lot like the motel is Shitz Creek.  Dirty, warn down, dormatory layout.  There is no viable internet (not enough or reliable enough to do work, so beware). 
Furniture is missing or just worn down.  Although relatively clean, no real complaints.
With few alternatives, renting a place for the week through a realty company, even though you  may not stay the entire week, is far more cost effective and comfortable.
This is a party hotel, so it is loud, lively drunken environment, which is fine, if that is what you are looking for (with not possibility of escape or solace).
There are not balconies, just juliette style railings at a swing door.  
Pets are allowed, but not allowed to stay in the room unattended.

2022 Summer The Grove Hotel Ice Palace Cherry Grove Fire Island

The upholstered headboard was torn and filthy.  There were long black hairs on the sheets.  The “balcony” is a tiny Juliet one; barely large enough to stand on.  No phone.

Although the front desk people were nice, $300 was ridiculous…and before the season!  I wouldn’t book here again if it were free.

Beware

Stayed at the Grove Hotel for an overnight with a friend who had never visited Fire Island and we both had an awesome time . Our second floor room had amazing views of tranquil Cherry Grove from ocean to bay . Concierge and staff are super helpful and friendly and our standard room was immaculate , spacious , and comfortable with extra blankets and a second bed you can pull out of couch . Lots of hot water in bathroom and I loved the moisturizing shampoo and soaps ! The pool is pristine with lots of deck space to lounge and being adjacent to beach and town is so ideal. 
I limited my phone use this time but will certainly have to snap some pics to add to this review when we return for a longer stay ! 

Michael P.

Definitely will be back ! Steps from beach and town

I understand the place is newly rebuilt, but the furniture is hideous and poorly designed for the space. The overall feeling is like being at a cheap motel you stumble upon after a long drive. The bathroom is also poorly designed. The hand-towel rack is too close to the floor and the sink area has no room to put toiletry bags or even a toothbrush. When we dropped something on the floor in the bedroom, we found fake rose petals under the bed. While this must have been part of a very romantic ritual for a previous occupant, it's kind of gross to find now, and shows how little the room was cleaned before our arrival. Finally, the tv only had 3 channels. And this all came at a high price room rate.

small poorly designed and dirty rooms

Had a pleasant stay with my friends at the Grove Hotel until I went to use the pool deck restroom and was aggressively approached and rebuffed by the Ice Palace/Grove Hotel manager. The bathroom was closed for cleaning; however rather than professionally explaining this inconvenience, the manager insinuated that I was trespassing on private property, arguing with me that “/if/ you’re a guest, you should just go and use your own, clean bathroom”.  His attitude was incredibly rude and unwelcoming. 

Moreover, when I spoke to this same manager afterwards to express my mistreatment, he inappropriately, condescendingly, and misogynistically addressed me, saying, “you misunderstood me, baby.” He continued on to argue that he had highest authority over both the Grove Hotel and the Ice Palace, thus implying that what I had to say didn’t matter to him. 

I commend the professionalism of the rest of the staff, but I want to make it known that this incident with the manager soiled the Grove Hotel’s reputation in my eyes. I would not recommend staying here.

Uncomfortable

It was a pleasure staying at the Grove hotel. My mom and I stayed and we enjoyed the new hotel. The rooms were nice, new and roomy for fire island. We enjoyed the nightly entertainment and activities. We loved the staff, by the end of the trip we felt like family Thanks, lacey for hosting us and being so thoughtful to my mom. 



Grove Hotel

Location

Available rooms

Location

Description of the hotel

What other amenities are there?

Policies

Check-in terms and conditions

Payment